The Garcia Family of My Father Cigars seems to come up with hit blend after hit blend. The Judge was created in 2016 as a fuller-bodied My Father cigar. This line extension was even shorter and fatter than the originals. Powered by Nicaraguan insides and a dark cover leaf of Ecuador Sumatra, the Grand Robusto has the look and taste of a chocolate bar, with sweet hints of peanuts, caramel and just a touch of red pepper spice. In a business where consistency is king, the Garcias deliver with this smoke: this is the second time this cigar has made our Top 25. In 2017, it made the list with the very same score of 93 points.